Women Who Blow on Knots by Ece Temelkuran

Women Who Blow On Knots Ece TemelkuranTranslated from the Turkish by Alexander Dawe, ‘Women Who Blow on Knots’ by Ece Temelkuran won the Edinburgh First Book Award earlier this year and I bought my copy during my visit to the city last summer. It tells the story of four women embarking on a road trip across North Africa from Tunisia to Lebanon during the Arab Spring. They are Tunisian activist and dancer Amira, Egyptian academic Maryam who is obsessed with Dido, Queen of Carthage, an unnamed Turkish journalist who narrates the story and the mysterious elderly Madam Lilla who has connections with the Russian mafia and intelligence agencies. It is Madam Lilla who invites the three women to accompany her on the trip although her real intentions for travelling to Lebanon only become clear much later.

Despite winning the Edinburgh First Book Award, ‘Women Who Blow on Knots’ is actually Temelkuran’s second novel but it is the first of her books to be translated into English. The title is taken from a verse in the Koran which refers to women practising witchcraft and the novel has rightfully gained attention for its refreshing depiction of modern Muslim female characters from diverse backgrounds and the sense of camaraderie between them which emerges during their journey. Temelkuran’s experience as a journalist fired from her job at a Turkish newspaper during a political crackdown by the Erdogan regime in 2012 appears to be a key source of inspiration and closely mirrors the situation of the unemployed narrator.

I was less keen on some of the digressions into magical realism and mythology and I found the tone a bit uneven in places – heavily intellectual in some parts while very light and frivolous in others – although it definitely succeeds in showcasing the diverse cultural influences in the region. The road trip element of the story is suitably pacy and the plot strikes a good balance between exploring the different personal motivations of each of the four women for embarking on the trip and the nuances of the political context of the Arab Spring.

Overall, ‘Women Who Blow on Knots’ is a striking and empowering novel which offers something genuinely different from the typical fictional depictions of the region often seen in the West and will hopefully lead the way towards the publication of more translated fiction in a similar vein written by women. Although the over-arching narrative might have benefitted from being more tightly written, there is still a lot to admire here, particularly in Temelkuran’s originality when it comes to the characterisation of her protagonists.


Filed under Books

6 responses to “Women Who Blow on Knots by Ece Temelkuran

  1. This vaguely reminds me of Three Daughters of Eve, the latest novel by Elif Shafak — interesting as she’s the only Turkish author I’ve read — in that it focuses on several women trying to negotiate their relationship to Islam and mixes in some magic realism. I love the title and the road trip idea.


    • Yes, they sound fairly similar in that respect although I haven’t read any of Shafak’s novels yet to compare.


      • I was keen to read something by the Young Writer judges (not that we’re necessarily going to meet them at the awards ceremony), so I read her latest via Edelweiss. I thought I’d also try Lucy Hughes-Hallett’s novel, but when I saw the cast list at the front I realized I was going to need to devote more time to that one, and probably have it in print rather than on Kindle.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. So a magic realism Thelma & Louise? 😂


  3. Pingback: The Man Booker International Prize 2018 Longlist Predictions | A Little Blog of Books

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.